The Penny Candy Store

Warehouse style candy store with over 2,000 candy selections for your personal indulgence, or wedding

Save
Share

Welcome to The Penny Candy Store, a treasure trove of sweets where you can indulge in a single piece of classic penny candy or stock up on old-fashioned favorites for the whole family. Our specialty lies in preserving the charm of yesteryear with penny candies dating back to the late 1800s and early 1900s, alongside a stunning array of colorful candies perfect for weddings and events. Enjoy nationwide shipping at a flat rate, ensuring great savings on any order.

Bring your family and friends along for the visit, as we proudly showcase a thousand varieties of old-fashioned candies. Discover our Exclusive Packages Category, featuring uniquely curated items, a hallmark of our store. Explore traditional treats like GOOD AND PLENTY® Candies, Bit O Honey, Mint Julep, Gummi Bears, Gummi Sharks, Peach Rings, Charleston Chews, Hershey’s Chocolate Bars, Sour Patch Watermelon, Sour Patch Peach, Sour Power Belts, Satellite Wafers, and Boston Fruit Slices.

With years of dedicated service, The Penny Candy Store is committed to providing our customers with the freshest, high-quality old-fashioned candies at accessible prices. We invite you to peruse all our delightful candy departments before making your way to the checkout area.